Thursday, May 17, 2018

New cartridges should all come with photos like these

The two cartridges belong to my friends. In my inspection I believe the cantilevers were both overly steep, resulting in the SRAs in the +96-degree range when the top surfaces were level. After adjustments at the factory, they came back included photos showing much more reasonable angles. For the cartridge manufacturers, providing such photos should be fairly easy, and such material will greatly help the users in correctly setting up the devices. Additionally, this makes monitoring the health of the cartridge much easier over time.
Note the angle of the coil is now only slightly away from parallel to the pole pieces. Adding tracking force and drag should put it into near perfect angle.

這是兩個針桿太陡的唱頭,原廠調整後寄回來,他們所附的照片。強烈建議所有新唱頭都應該附上這樣的照片,對用家來說會少很多調整上的麻煩。日後也容易追蹤健康狀況的變化。
注意現在線圈的角度,只偏離磁鐵的平面一點,加上針壓等外力,就應該與前後的磁鐵平行了。

No automatic alt text available.

Image may contain: indoor

Tuesday, May 1, 2018

"Powerful Bass" of Phono Stages?

When some people/reviewers commented certain phono stage has "powerful bass", it's better to take it with a grain of salt. Unlike pre-amps or power amps which do not have any EQ circuit in their signal paths, a phono stage has a reverse-RIAA EQ built in. And some designers will "cheat" a little by tweaking the EQ curve to achieve the desired "sound" for the device. So when we find a phono stage to have very impressive bass performance, it's likely not from the superior circuit design or strong power supply unit, just a trick of modifying the EQ. 

The three phono stages tested below are all priced at the ~8000 USD range. Using the same cartridge Lyra Kleos (without changing any parameters) to feed the test signal, I measured the high-frequency responses to be virtually identical. Whereas below 5kHz, the 2nd and 3rd devices obviously display higher output levels, ranging from a couple of dB to the extreme case of nearly 5 dB at the lowest end of the spectrum.

Incidentally, the first two are UK brands, and the 3rd one from the USA. In my experience, phono stages made by the US-based brands tend to have boosted bass responses similar to the 3rd device.

前後級擴大機沒有等化線路,而唱頭放大就必須有「反」RIAA等化。低頻很厲害的唱放,其實可能只是在等化曲線上做了些手腳,並非它的線路或電源部分有多特別。如下面3個圖的比較,用同一個唱頭不改變任何參數,得到的高頻響應幾乎完全相同。但 5kHz以下的,就開始出現明顯的差異。這3台的美金定價都在8000左右,前2台是英國牌子,第3台是美國的。



Tuesday, April 24, 2018

IMD numbers of the ELP laser player

What kind of IMD numbers the ELP laser player will show if running the AnalogMagik's VTA test through it? The ELP uses two ~2-micron laser "dots" to read the groove hence no SRA-related issue. IMD should be very low in theory. Initial measurements below show pretty good numbers, though not much better than a well-adjusted cartridge. I suspect the test record needs to be cleaned even further to get better measurements due to the ELP's susceptibility to dust. In any case, at least this shows AnalogMagik's IMD measurements are mostly in line with expectations.
在 ELP 黑膠雷射唱盤,用 AnalogMagik 的 VTA測試,會得到什麼結果?初始測試顯示,IMD 數值算相當不錯,但沒有比調整得好的唱頭更低。因為 ELP 對灰塵很敏感,可能要把測試唱片洗得更乾淨,才會有更好的結果。但這些數值至少顯示,AnalogMagik的 IMD 測量是有可信度的。而且,之前一直認為 ELP 的聲音雖然細節少,但失真很低,是有其道理的。

Monday, April 23, 2018

Using AnalogMagik to Tune London Reference's VTA/SRA


Most Decca-family cartridges have their styli slanted backward as in Figure 1. Naturally, one would assume the tone arm should be raised to achieve better sound. When using AnalogMagik's VTA function to test my London Reference, I found just the opposite. When the top of the cartridge was level, the IMD measured in the 8% range, and jump to ~12% if I raised the arm slightly higher. Only when I tilted back the cartridge to the extreme (as in Figure 2) did I get the best IMD numbers. The sound? Surprisingly delicate, detailed and clean with super dark background, very different from the rough-around-the-edges character that most people expect from Decca cartridges.

Decca 系列唱頭,針尖看起來多數是後仰的,我的 London Reference 也如此,如圖一,所以多數人都會把唱臂調高。但用 AnalogMagik 的 VTA 功能測 IMD, 唱頭上緣水平時 IMD竟然高達8%。再調高更不好,到 12%。反方向把唱頭調低到不能再低,後端快碰到唱片表面(如圖二),才出現不錯的數字如圖三。聽起來如何?出人意料的細膩乾淨又安靜,以前以為 Decca 系列唱頭固有的,稍微不修邊幅個性,竟然都不見了。這真是令人跌破眼鏡的結果。

No automatic alt text available.

Image may contain: indoor

No automatic alt text available.

Thursday, April 12, 2018

Different power supply units leading to visible S/N ratio differences

Different power supply units leading to visible S/N ratio differences: Using the "Gain" optimization function in AnalogMagik, I measured the S/N numbers on iPhono 2 with its own switching-type PSU (Figure 1) and a large linear PSU by Acopian (Figure 2). The difference is about 1dB and quite consistent in various measurements.

AnalogMagik 有個原本用來找最佳放大倍率的功能,我以它測了不同電源供應給 iPhono 2 的 S/N (訊噪)比。圖一是原廠的切換式電源,圖二是 Acopian 的線性電源。測出的差別不大,約1 dB左右,但數據相當的 consistent。

No automatic alt text available.
No automatic alt text available.

Thursday, March 29, 2018

Tracking Tests on the ELP Laser Turntable

An ELP uses laser beams to pick up the signals (no digitization!) without physically touching the groove surface. One may think the distortion level would be much lower than using a stylus since there's no friction involved, and there would be no tracking issue at all. However, in reality there are other factors involved and the test results could be somewhat unexpected.

Using the eight tracking tests on the Hi-Fi News test record, the results are shown below. Some key observations:

1) Harmonic distortions, especially the 2nd and 3rd-order, are still quite visible on the spectrum analyzer, mostly similar to the case of using a regular stereo cartridge.

2) The strongest test signal in Test#4 leads to very high distortion, as can be seen in the deformed sine wave form. This level of distortion is in fact worse than some of the better tracking cartridges. But the good thing is, there's no skipping like in some cartridges' case.

3) From Test#3 to Test#4, the distortion level increases drastically, even though the difference in signal strength is only 2dB higher. Seems like somewhere between +16 to +18 dB, the threshold of the ELP's tracking capability has been crossed.

4) Tests#5, 6 and 7 corresponds to outer, middle and inner part of the record surface, respectively. The difference among them is smaller than most cartridges, showing the lack of side force interference is an advantage for the ELP.

5) Some unusual spikes in the spectrum are likely from dust particles on the record surface. The ELP cannot push away dirt in the groove like a stylus.


用 ELP 播放 Hi-Fi News 測試唱片的8個循軌測試軌,目前的觀察:

1) 播放時諧波失真也是普遍存在,所以這些失真的來源並非因唱針與溝槽摩擦而產生。觀察 TESTS#1到4,比起抗滑/側向力調整得好的唱頭/唱臂,失真率並沒有較低。

2)強度高的訊號如 TEST#4,ELP 也是會有嚴重失真,可見內部的雷射換能機構還是有遲緩的弱點。但優點是完全不會有跳針現象,而且左右波型都還相當平衡。

3)從 TEST#3 到 #4,失真的差異很大,猜測是剛好超跨過了 ELP 循軌能力的 threshold。

4)從 TESTS#5,6,與7看來,內外圈的差異相當小,較一般支點臂 consistent。

5)頻譜裡有些奇怪的雜訊,應該是唱片表面灰塵造成雷射的反應,判讀時應該將之忽略。



TEST#1

#2

#3

#4

#5

#6

#7

#8


Tuesday, March 27, 2018

How to Deal with Skewed Zenith?

Stereophile 的 Michael Fremer 在這文提到這個鮮少被人注意的參數:

http://www.analogplanet.com/content/stylus-zenith-angle-heretofore-neglected-set-parameter-considered#Pq2fSHWlKpbXrJBT.97

基本上,它關係到的是針尖與唱片接觸的那個「面」,與針桿之間是否為平行。一般用針桿來調循軌角時,都假設這不是問題。但實際上,並非總是如此。

目前我的看法是,如果沒有太歪,而且知道角度差多少,應該可透過循軌角的改變來做修正。從 Adjust+ 測量許多唱頭的數據來看,除非與標準值偏離得離譜,否則循軌角與zenith主要的影響,是在左右聲道相位延遲的差別。如果測出來左右聲道的延遲差異很大 (我見過差超過100度的名牌高價頭),那最好用顯微鏡看一下 zenith 是不是歪很多。

以下是我自己照的幾個唱頭的 zenith 。

這是圓錐形的針尖,所以不必考慮 SRA 或 zenith 的問題。





這是一個 Nagaoka 的唱頭。看起來 zenith 是很正。





這是我的 Lyra Delos,因為廠方用了太多粘膠來固定針尖,所以不容易看清。



這是一個老的 Lyra Skala,似乎是有點歪。